Greta Gerwig's 2023 blockbuster film Barbie has become a sensation in popular culture. The movie is now in the running for the Best Picture award at the 96th Academy Awards. It has received a total of eight Oscar nominations, including a nod for Best Supporting Actress for America Ferrera and Best Supporting Actor for Ryan Gosling. Sadly, Margot Robbie did not secure a nomination. Although Gerwig was recognized for Best Adapted Screenplay, she was notably absent from the Best Director category. This decision has disappointed many fans who believe that her talent and contribution to the film should have been recognized.

Additionally, some skeptics have expressed doubts about Ferrera's nomination, questioning whether her performance in the film truly deserves an Oscar nod.

Ferrera's work in Barbie earned critical acclaim, especially for her powerful monologue in the latter part of the movie. This monologue, which addresses the complexities of womanhood, has been praised as an inspiring piece. However, some individuals feel that Ferrera's overall performance was lacking and that the monologue would have been more compelling if delivered by Margot Robbie.

As a result, discussions have emerged surrounding the contention that Ferrera's performance in Barbie does not merit an Oscar nomination.

Many critics argue that if the nomination is based on the impactful monologue, credit should be given to the writers rather than Ferrera. Some assert that they have witnessed more inspirational speeches from fictional characters like Optimus Prime. Furthermore, there are debates regarding the justification for Ferrera's nomination, with some describing her acting as mediocre. These debates highlight a divide among audiences regarding the recognition Ferrera has received.